This was a good brownie. Rich, sweet, dense, moist. I would not, however, say that BHB is justified in calling this a S'mores brownie. There was only one little marshmallow on top and no graham that I could detect. It seemed to me to be a decent brownie with a random marshmallow that landed there on accident. When I think s'mores I think lots of gooey marshmallows with some crunch from the graham. If I was going to make a s'mores brownie (and now maybe I will, because I kind of want one!) I would make some kind of bottom crust with graham incorporated into it, a rich chocolate brownie-probably with some dark chocolate incorporated to balance out some of the sweetness- and then do a thin layer of marshmallows on top. I don't think that I would buy this brownie. It was good, but not great, and I am guessing that it is pretty pricey (most things from this bakery are). To me, a brownie is a brownie, and this one did not break that mold at all.